The Harder They Fall
The bad news keeps piling up for Nvidia... The bigger they are, the harder they fall... The stock hasn't been this cheap in 13 years... It's all setting up a trade – and a trend...
It just keeps getting worse for Nvidia (NVDA)...
Early this year, months before most people had heard the name Alice Huang, Indonesian police showed up at an office in Jakarta.
The FBI had asked them to search for Nvidia chips at PT Megaspeed International Indonesia, the local arm of Singapore-based cloud-computing company Megaspeed.
Investigators found server racks that, reportedly, nobody had ever unpacked. What they didn't find were graphics processing units ("GPUs"), the AI chips that were supposed to go inside.
So where'd the chips go?
Singapore's Straits Times, the most widely circulated newspaper in the country, broke the story today.
A senior Indonesian government official told the paper that most of the Nvidia hardware that Megaspeed entities bought likely went to Indonesia first... before moving on to China – possibly by private jet.
None of that has been independently confirmed by any government, and may never be. Nvidia has said its own review found no evidence of smuggling. But that doesn't mean it didn't happen.
And speculation like this is a big concern for Nvidia and the AI-driven bull market in general.
Every red flag is now getting attention...
In late 2024, a U.S. Commerce Department official reportedly found Nvidia gear still sealed in boxes at a Megaspeed data center in Malaysia.
U.S. intelligence then reportedly began watching a Megaspeed executive... Alice Huang.
The world now knows the rest.
Jensen Huang, who admitted to an affair with the alleged Chinese operative, resigned as Nvidia's CEO last Thursday, following reports of a second relationship with an Nvidia executive who reported to him. A third allegation, with a second Nvidia employee, has been reported for good measure.
Affairs are one thing... Covertly, or even unknowingly, selling to China is another...
As we wrote a week ago, the scandal would matter most for the stock if Huang left or was forced out of the company he co-founded. Now he has. And I (Corey McLaughlin) think today's news and continued fallout is a bigger problem for Huang than the affairs ever were.
The market can forgive a CEO's personal life. It will have a much harder time looking past a company letting its best chips flow to China – if that's what happened.
Washington wants to know the truth (or at least give that perception)… and that might weigh on whoever becomes Nvidia's permanent CEO.
On Fox News over the weekend, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent called for a "dramatic shake-up" and answers from Nvidia's board and outside lawyers within 10 days.
That's a long way from the friendly treatment Huang enjoyed in Washington for most of this year, where he sat directly next to President Donald Trump at a meeting of the AI minds not long ago.
In the meantime, growth expectations are falling...
Chip-research firm SemiAnalysis has cut its forecast for 2028 global spending on AI accelerators – the chips Nvidia sells – by 28%, to $758 billion from more than $1 trillion.
If that's right, it means AI spending growth may have already peaked. As we've said for several years now, the AI bull market reckoning will come when AI spending slows down.
Well, here we may be...
Nvidia's market cap is down to around $3.8 trillion today from a peak of $5.8 trillion on October 6.
Apple (AAPL), considered by some the laggard in the AI race when it comes to the major tech companies, has overtaken Nvidia as the largest U.S. company by market cap... trading at more than $5 trillion.
But there's always tomorrow...
Nvidia reports quarterly earnings after tomorrow's close – its first report without Huang – just as Trump happens to head to China to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping. (How timely.)
Maybe the company's report – and interim CEO Colette Kress' comments – will ease some fears.
What we do know is that narratives can change quickly, as we've just seen, and Nvidia is more beaten down than it has been in almost a decade. The bigger they are, the harder they fall.
Nvidia's shares are already down almost 35% from their 52-week high of around $243. At less than 11 times forward earnings (which the stock hasn't traded at since 2013), shares aren't trading on valuation right now. They're trading on sentiment.
Maybe that'll change some tomorrow. Maybe not.
The most important decision Nvidia's board will make...
The big question over the long run for Nvidia is who runs the company next?
For now, Kress is the interim boss. She and Ian Buck, a top Nvidia engineer, are reportedly in the running for the permanent job. But on the day Nvidia's board announced Huang's resignation, it said it would consider "internal" and "external" candidates to replace him.
Trump has floated Apple chairman Tim Cook. We've also heard that rival chipmaking CEOs could be recruited over to Nvidia.
Given the circumstances, it looks like an outsider would do the most for the stock – for two reasons...
First, "Nvidia" is suddenly a dirty word, especially in Washington, which will play an increasingly larger role in AI regulation beginning in January. Any insider, fairly or not, comes with the question of what they knew about any chips that may have gone to China and how close they were to Jensen Huang. A fresh face from outside can say, credibly, they weren't close to the problem.
Second, business strategy... Nvidia has spent the past few years investing in and financing many of its own customers. Kress, as the longtime chief financial officer, is perceived as the more cautious steward of the company's cash. If she – or any new CEO – dials back those "circular" deals, some smaller or weakly perceived AI companies may not have the money to keep buying chips at the same pace. That might warrant lower growth expectations and threaten to slow down the entire AI boom.
The right outsider could ease both risks.
One thing is for sure: Don't count on a Huang comeback...
Yesterday, the Financial Times reported that Huang was weighing a return as CEO, with allies inside the company and across Silicon Valley lobbying the board. Today, Trump said he supports the idea.
By this afternoon, CNBC was reporting that Nvidia's board isn't considering bringing Huang back, citing a source close to the situation.
Our colleague Whitney Tilson never bought the idea. As he wrote in his free daily e-letter today...
Don't be fooled by this noise. Nvidia's board members have bigger things to worry about right now...
Namely, Whitney says, like staying out of a congressional hearing room.
He pointed to a Fortune column from Yale's Jeff Sonnenfeld, which argues that bringing Huang back before the investigation into his conduct is finished would put the subject of the probe in charge of the people running it. It just doesn't make sense.
Still, Whitney had a word of caution for anyone tempted to dump everything AI-related.
He noted that the big AI "hyperscalers" are growing revenue at about 21% on average, yet trade around 21 times earnings... while slow-growers like Costco Wholesale (COST) and Walmart (WMT) trade around 40 times.
Whitney remains bullish on Alphabet (GOOGL), Amazon (AMZN), Meta Platforms (META), and Microsoft (MSFT).
Nvidia's mess – while big and growing – isn't the whole AI story.
All this bad news could set up a trade...
Our colleague and technical analyst Greg Diamond, the editor of Ten Stock Trader, sees an opportunity forming in semiconductors.
In his Weekly Market Outlook this morning, Greg walked through what Nvidia's charts are signaling heading into earnings – and why the bigger opportunity may be in a couple of its rivals.
If the setup he's watching plays out over the next week or two, Greg says it would be "a huge buy signal" and potentially "another doubling window."
Greg trades these moves with options. Just last week, his subscribers closed a trade on Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) calls for a 217% gain in four days.
Click here to learn how to join Greg's Ten Stock Trader service before his next buy signal. Existing Ten Stock Trader subscribers, you can find Greg's full outlook here.
Meanwhile, the rotation to quality rolls on...
Tech stocks led the way lower today.
The Nasdaq Composite Index fell 2.5% and the S&P 500 Index lost 1.9%, with Nvidia down 4% and AI stocks broadly weaker. Consumer staples and utilities were the bright or "least bad" spots, up slightly.
And this isn't a one-day occurrence. We've noted rotation into these sectors over the past several months...
The healthcare sector of the S&P 500, which was just 0.5% lower today, is up about 13% in the past three months, the best-performing sector in that span. Consumer staples is next-best, up about 8.5%, while tech is down 13%, including more than 3% today.
Our colleague Dan Ferris explained what this may mean in his Friday Digest. His view: The AI boom is in a "topping process."
As Dan explained, a bottom is usually a single moment. A top plays out over time, as former leaders weaken, fewer stocks carry the market, and money rotates elsewhere. The indexes can even keep making new highs along the way.
Dan's evidence is hard to ignore...
AI names like CoreWeave (CRWV) and Oracle (ORCL) are in outright bear markets. Meanwhile, the 10 largest stocks make up nearly 40% of the S&P 500, a bigger share than at the dot-com peak. And money has been moving into healthcare, energy, financials, and big defensive names.
If you take nothing else from today's Digest, let it be this...
The market is rewarding quality right now. That means good businesses with durable cash flows, bought at reasonable prices... not whatever happens to be biggest in an index fund.
That doesn't mean abandoning AI altogether, as Whitney cautioned. But it does mean not letting one company's headlines or fallen CEO run your whole portfolio.
The market's great divide may just be getting started...
The rotation is one reason our friends Joel Litman and Brett Eversole are sounding an alarm... and seeing an opportunity.
Joel, the founder of our corporate affiliate Altimetry, and Brett, the editor of True Wealth, believe the U.S. stock market could be heading for its most dramatic split between winners and losers in 25 years.
You see, beneath the indexes' gains, Joel and Brett say nearly 60% of S&P 500 companies are already in bear market territory... and just five stocks have accounted for 93% of the index's gains since July.
But Joel and Brett also see a catalyst coming fast: the Federal Reserve's December 9 meeting.
If the Fed raises rates to fight inflation, as they expect, debt-heavy businesses could get squeezed further... while companies that earn far more on their capital than it costs them to borrow keep pulling ahead.
So for the first time, Joel and Brett have combined their two systems.
Joel's accounting analysis strips out the distortions in standard financial statements to find companies that are more profitable than they look. Meantime, Brett uses dozens of market trackers to show where money is flowing.
Stocks that pass both tests – what they call "Perfect Breakouts" – are rare.
Their research found just 220 over 15 years. But Joel and Brett believe this select group could deliver gains of up to 6 times your money, even while much of the market struggles in 2027.
Joel and Brett lay out the full story – including how to spot these stocks before the Fed's December decision – in a brand-new event this Thursday, November 19, at 10 a.m. Eastern time. The event is free – they just ask that you sign up in advance of Thursday.
Click here to reserve your spot for Joel and Brett's event now.
New 52-week highs (as of 11/13/26): AbbVie (ABBV), Automatic Data Processing (ADP), Alpha Architect 1-3 Month Box Fund (BOXX), Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-B), CBOE Global Markets (CBOE), Colgate-Palmolive (CL), Costco Wholesale (COST), Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), Coca-Cola (KO), Eli Lilly (LLY), Mobility Global (MBGL), Altria (MO), Procter & Gamble (PG), Tradeweb Markets (TW), Invesco DB U.S. Dollar Index Bullish Fund (UUP), and State Street Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLP).
In today's mailbag, thoughts on – what else – Nvidia and AI... Do you have a comment or question? As always, e-mail us at feedback@stansberryresearch.com.
"Nvidia's acting like a bank, prompting some to say it's playing a 'balance sheet as a service' game. I think you should coin the phrase BullSaaS for the circular financing games it played!" – Subscriber Jon C.
"AI is a commodity. The only way to make money producing a commodity is high, even huge, volume. That is because the only way to compete in commodities is by price. The highest volume and lowest cost producers are the ones who make money. The money they make per unit is abysmally low. And customer loyalty is directly related to price." – Subscriber N.B.
All the best,
Corey McLaughlin
Baltimore, Maryland
November 16, 2026
