My worst investment of all time; Tech bros petition to bring Jensen Huang back to Nvidia; Comparing hyperscalers with slow-growth businesses

1) I recently did an interview with businessman Andrew Stotz for his podcast called My Worst Investment Ever. We had a wide-ranging conversation for more than 50 minutes, which you can listen to and read a summary of here.

As the summary recounts, my second-worst investment mistake ever was shorting Tesla (TSLA) 13 years ago:

In 2013, Whitney was short Tesla. He had seen another ambitious electric-vehicle venture, Better Place, fail and believed Tesla faced serious financial and execution risks. Tesla, however, was just days from running out of cash before it launched the Model S, and the launch succeeded. Whitney says he was too slow to recognize that the business had changed.

The stock tore against Whitney's short for more than a year. What began as a position representing roughly 1%-1.5% of his portfolio generated a loss of approximately 500% on the short position – not on his entire portfolio...

What finally got him out wasn't a chart. It was a phone call. His cousin, a Stanford engineer, put him in touch with two of Tesla's top battery and automotive engineers, who told him the company was roughly six years ahead of every other automaker on everything related to electric vehicles. Whitney covered his short that day, at a steep loss, and admits he should have flipped around and gone long instead.

But my No. 1 mistake was selling Netflix (NFLX) far too soon. As the summary continues, I was short before I went long:

A couple of years before the Tesla short, he had also been short Netflix and gotten badly burned, so badly that he published a public 18-page essay explaining why he was short the stock.

Netflix co-founder Reed Hastings, whom Whitney knew from serving together on charter-school boards, published a friendly rebuttal days later and invited Whitney out to California to talk it through in person. Whitney left that meeting and immediately covered his Netflix short.

A year and a half later, Netflix's stock had collapsed by 75% to a $3 billion market cap, exactly as his original short thesis had predicted. Rather than re-shorting, Whitney now respected Hastings and the business.

In October 2012, he went long instead, publicly comparing Netflix to Amazon a decade earlier: same customer growth, same revenue trajectory, but a company that was actually profitable and debt-free. He predicted Netflix could be "this decade's Amazon," a 20-bagger in the making.

It was the right call – but I made the wrong move at the wrong time:

Whitney was dramatically underestimating his own prediction. Split-adjusted, Netflix went from roughly $8 to $800 a share over the following eight years, a hundredfold return. Whitney didn't stay for the ride.

After the stock doubled, he sold half. After it doubled again, he sold half of what remained, and exited not long after. He walked away with about seven times his money, which sounds like a win until you consider what patience alone would have delivered. "I left a 12-bagger on the table," he says of the gains still to come in Netflix's next five years alone.

I'll keep saying it until I'm blue in the face: You have to let your winners run!

2) The unfolding scandal related to Nvidia (NVDA) founder and former CEO Jensen Huang continues to dominate headlines – rightly so, given the implications for national security, our relationship with China, a possible trade war, and the stock market.

The Financial Times reported that Huang is considering a comeback as CEO, as many allies inside the company and across Silicon Valley put pressure on the board.

There's even a "Stand With Jensen" petition demanding Huang's reinstatement, as this Wall Street Journal article reports. It currently has around 175,000 signatures, including tech titans like Elon Musk.

Don't be fooled by this noise. Nvidia's board members have bigger things to worry about right now... Their main concern is avoiding being dragged in front of Congress and/or possibly going to prison.

My friend from Yale, Jeff Sonnenfeld, nails it in this Fortune article: What a Tiny Chorus of the 'Bring Back Jensen' Tech Bros Gets Wrong. He concludes:

The unresolved questions argue for letting investigators finish their work, and the loudest calls to keep Huang's return alive come from those with the most to lose. Reinstating Huang by petition before the inquiry into his own conduct concludes would place the subject of the investigation directly above the people conducting it...

Nvidia's directors spent three decades deferring to one man and one week governing. Shareholders should insist the governing continue.

Ultimately, Jensen Huang built one of the great companies in American history. But that does not earn him a waiver from U.S. national security, chip export laws, securities laws or his own code of conduct, no matter how much noise a small circle of rogue tech bros make on X.

This tech bro mob must think that Huang should embrace Cornelius Vanderbilt's retort, "Law, what law? I am the law."

3) While I remain bearish on Nvidia and the AI bubble, I would echo the caution from my friend and famed short seller Jim Chanos. In a recent X post, he warned:

Related to his point, check out this X post from Boring_Business. It compares the revenue growth and price to earnings (P/E) of AI hyperscalers versus slow-growers:

The market is so negative on AI capex spend that hyperscalers with an average 21% revenue growth are trading at a 20.7x P/E multiple.

Meanwhile, you have companies like Costco and Walmart trading at 40x P/E while growing revenue at a fraction of the rate

If the capex proves to have any reasonable [return on investment], people are going to deeply regret being this bearish on some of the best companies in the world

Here's the table from the post with the full breakdown:

I continue to be bullish on four of the five hyperscalers: Alphabet (GOOGL), Amazon (AMZN), Meta Platforms (META), and Microsoft (MSFT).

As I've outlined in many previous e-mails, they have highly profitable, dominant businesses that will benefit from their huge investments in AI – even if (or when) the bubble bursts.

Best regards,

Whitney

P.S. I welcome your feedback – send me an e-mail by clicking here.

P.P.S. Every year or two, my cousins and I organize a guys' get-together. For this year's, we met in Eugene, Oregon over the weekend (minus one who couldn't get in due to the airline shutdown). My cousin Brice graduated from the University of Oregon in 2019 and lives in the area, so we all went to the big football game against the University of Michigan. The stadium was a madhouse – a sea of green – and the Ducks won handily:

On the drive back to Portland yesterday for our flights home, we stopped for three hours at the North American Aerospace Museum, which is outstanding. It's best known for being the permanent home of Howard Hughes' legendary "Spruce Goose," the world's largest wooden flying boat (which only flew once, for 26 seconds). It also houses the coolest aircraft ever built, in my opinion – the SR-71 Blackbird:

Subscribe to Whitney Tilson's Daily for FREE
Get the Whitney Tilson's Daily delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam pledge: We'll never rent, misuse or abuse your email address. By entering your e-mail, you will also begin receiving Whitney Tilson's Daily. You can unsubscribe from Whitney Tilson's Daily at any time. Privacy Policy.

Recent ArticlesView Full Archives
Back to Top