
Your Index Fund Is Now an AI Bet
Editor's note: Index funds have long been a go-to choice for investors who want broad market exposure without making individual stock picks. But according to Joel Litman, chief investment officer of our corporate affiliate Altimetry, the S&P 500 looks a lot different than it did 10 years ago. Nearly half its value now rests in one trade. That concentration can work wonders on the way up... and create serious problems when the trade turns...
Big Tech didn't always dominate the S&P 500 Index...
In late 2016, the information technology ("IT") and communication services sectors made up just 23.4% of the index's value.
However, tech's slice has more than doubled in a single decade...
These same sectors made up 49.6% of the index's market value last month. That's partly due to companies like Google parent Alphabet (GOOGL) and Facebook owner Meta Platforms (META).
The pitch for index funds, like the Vanguard S&P 500 Fund (VOO), used to be simple: Buy the S&P 500 and own a bit of the whole U.S. economy, from banks to railroads.
Today, about half of every dollar you put into an index fund goes to the companies riding the AI boom.
If you feel like the market is fixated on AI, you're not alone. And as we'll explain, it's changing how investors "play it safe"...
The Market Is Built on One Big Bet
For most of the past decade, the tech concentration has carried the S&P 500...
The IT sector alone has climbed an average of 22.7% annually over the past 10 years. That's enough to turn $10,000 into roughly $77,500.
As innovation evolved, tech stocks scooped up more and more of the index's value. Check it out...
In 10 years, tech went from less than a quarter of the S&P 500's value to nearly half.
That run has made index investors a lot of money. And that trend may continue. After all, we still believe in the AI build-out over the long haul.
The issue is concentration. With so much riding on one theme, the whole index moves with it... in both directions.
The AI Trade Is Hitting a Political Speedbump
After the midterms, investors saw what that looks like on the way down...
Democrats swept congressional seats across the country on November 3.
The party's wins signaled voters' resistance to data centers – the giant warehouses that host the computer servers powering AI. Newly elected governors in seven states had also pledged to stop or pause data-center construction.
Investors started to worry that these roadblocks would slow down the AI build-out... and with it, demand for chips and other gear.
So they sold their tech stocks. The S&P 500 fell 4.4% on November 5 – its worst day since April 2025.
The IT sector fell hardest, plunging 7.3%. Chipmaker Nvidia (NVDA), the world's most valuable company until recently, lost more than $446 billion in market value.
Then the damage spread. All 11 sectors in the S&P 500 tanked. And about $2.3 trillion of stock market value disappeared in a single day.
Part of the reason has to do with programming...
Many big funds run on computers programmed to buy when prices rise and sell when they fall. So once the S&P 500 dropped below "key levels," like the average price over the past 50 or 200 days, the sell-off began automatically.
These funds cover the whole market, which is why companies unrelated to AI got dragged down, too.
So what was built to be diversified, with 500 stocks across 11 sectors, now rises and falls with one trade.
That doesn't make tech a bad investment. But it does mean that "parking it in the index" isn't the low-risk move many folks assume it is.
You need to know what assets you own. Pull up your index fund's sector breakdown on its website. If half of your money is riding on one theme, make sure you're comfortable with that bet.
You need a plan for a market that can drop 4% in a day.
That's why I've teamed up with Brett Eversole to help investors navigate this environment.
Major indexes have been bruised this month, and more and more individual stocks are struggling. And on December 9, that divide could become even more extreme.
So Brett and I are joining forces to uncover companies with exceptional financial strength and industries experiencing powerful upward momentum. Our strategy could help you uncover stocks that double, triple, or even rise sixfold.
Don't let the next big market swing expose your portfolio. Make sure you're prepared.
Regards,
Joel Litman
Editor's note: The stock market is approaching a key turning point. And some of today's biggest winners could be in trouble. That's why Joel and Brett just teamed up for their "Financial Survival Summit" – explaining what's changing... the new group of stocks positioned to benefit... and what investors should do next.
Further Reading
Political uncertainty has put a lot of pressure on the AI trade. Now, semiconductor stocks are showing signs of an extreme sell-off. But a look at nearly three decades of market history suggests this kind of weakness can create an attractive opportunity.
The biggest market headlines are focused on falling technology stocks and the future of AI. But a deeper look unveils a much healthier picture. The S&P 500's structure can make a broad market decline look worse than it really is – and hide where opportunities are emerging.

