Wall Street's Scariest Bubble Warning Is Wrong

Editor's note: The markets have been volatile since the midterm elections. Many investors worry that the AI trade is nearing its peak. But according to Joel Litman, founder of our corporate affiliate Altimetry, the facts don't support those fears. In this issue, adapted from the free Altimetry Daily Authority e-letter, he analyzes two key financial metrics... which suggest the AI boom is not over.


The cries are getting louder by the week...

A growing crowd of "pros" say the AI trade has pushed stocks into bubble territory. They include billionaires like Bridgewater Associates founder Ray Dalio and crypto investor Michael Novogratz.

The bears have a scary number on their side. They're looking at the Shiller cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ("CAPE") ratio. It compares stock prices with the past 10 years of inflation-adjusted earnings.

Right now, the ratio sits around 40. That's more than double its long-term average of about 17. And it's not far from the record of 44, which was set in 1999 – right before the dot-com bubble burst.

But one of the world's foremost bubble experts isn't worried yet.

I'm talking about Howard Marks, co-chair of investment firm Oaktree Capital Management. He's famous for his memos on market cycles... and for calling the top of the dot-com market.

Last month, Marks said he wasn't convinced today's market is a bubble. And as you'll see, I agree with him...

What Makes a Bubble?

To Marks, a bubble takes more than high prices...

It takes a public mania where some folks get absurdly rich... and anyone on the sidelines feels foolish.

Marks also calls bubbles a form of reckless optimism. "Obliviousness is another good word," he told Bloomberg News.

In a bubble, investors stop seeing risk at all. But today, risk seems to be the only thing that people on Wall Street are talking about.

During second-quarter earnings season, executives and analysts on 15 different calls compared today's market with the tech bubble or the 2008 financial crisis.

That's why Marks thinks that if a bubble does exist, it's probably a restrained one. When this many people are being cautious, the market has a built-in brake.

Nervous investors take profits. They refuse to chase the wildest ideas.

Numbers Don't Lie

That brings us back to the CAPE ratio. You see, once you fix the accounting behind it, the numbers look a lot different...

Like the standard price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, the CAPE ratio divides stock prices by as-reported earnings. Those are the numbers companies publish under generally accepted accounting principles ("GAAP").

But what you might not know is that GAAP distorts what companies earn.

Take research and development (R&D) spending, for instance. R&D builds products that pay off years down the line.

But GAAP doesn't wait for those costs to pay off. It counts every dollar as an expense the year it's spent. Reported earnings shrink as a result... which makes the P/E ratio look bigger.

The distortion hits hardest for tech companies that spend heavily on R&D. And those companies now make up about 40% of the S&P 500.

CAPE inherits every one of those flaws...

Even the headline numbers show that today isn't 1999. A month before the dot-com peak in 2000, the five biggest tech stocks in the S&P 500 traded at about 65 times forward earnings.

Today's five biggest stocks trade at around 23 times.

At Altimetry, we use Uniform Accounting to fix these as-reported P/E distortions. To see the difference, we took the top 10 companies by market cap every year from 1999 to 2026. We calculated their average Uniform P/E each year and compared it with the average CAPE ratio.

Back in 1999, both measures were sky-high. CAPE hit that record of 44 I mentioned above... and the 10 biggest companies traded at 39 times forward Uniform earnings. By 2000, they had climbed to 44 times.

The two metrics tell different stories today, though. The CAPE ratio is back near 40. But the market's 10 biggest companies trade at about 23 times Uniform earnings.

That's roughly half their dot-com peak. And it's close to their long-term average of about 22 times.

Take a look...

After cleaning up the accounting, we see that today's market leaders look nothing like the dot-com darlings.

Valuations are just a bit above the long-term average.

Remember, a bubble occurs when folks stop expecting one...

But Marks – the investor best known for spotting bubbles – doesn't believe we're in one today. And the Uniform numbers agree with him.

Don't let the bubble headlines scare you out of the market. It's true that we're seeing a lot of volatility. Parts of the market are in danger of a dip.

But selling everything would be a great way to miss the next leg of the AI boom.

Let the crowd keep worrying. As long as it does, we'll stay invested.

Regards,

Joel Litman


Editor's note: Joel has called nearly every market crash of the past 20 years, and he sees some early warning signs forming today. That's why he's joining forces with our own Brett Eversole tomorrow at 10 a.m. Eastern time for a free online event. They'll explain what's next for U.S. stocks and share the ONE move you must make now to prepare. Reserve your spot for their Financial Survival Summit here.

Further Reading

Investors may be starting to get nervous... but they're still holding a lot of stock. In fact, on average, individual investors today have their highest allocation to stocks since 2017. And surprisingly, that's a positive sign for returns going forward.

It's tempting to wait for an asset to drop before buying in... especially when the "experts" are calling for a top. But that mindset will lead to missed opportunities. The best time to act is now.

Back to Top