An analysis of Nvidia's earnings report; More questions about connections to China
AI-sector bellwether Nvidia (NVDA) reported third-quarter earnings and boosted guidance after the market close yesterday...
(Here's the press release, investor presentation, CFO commentary, and supplemental financial information.)
It was a blockbuster quarter. Revenue soared 20% from the previous quarter and 103% year over year ("YOY"), beating expectations by 6% – above its usual 4% beat. Adjusted earnings per share were $2.68, up 21% from the previous quarter and 111% YOY – 8% above estimates of $2.47.
The company returned a record $28.1 billion to shareholders in the third quarter – $6 billion in dividends and $22.1 billion in share repurchases. This reduced the diluted share count by 1.2%. And $227 billion remains on its share-buyback authorization, which Nvidia plans to complete by January 2028.
Everyone knew it was going to be a great quarter, as it covered the three months ending on October 25, which was the peak of the AI bubble (in my opinion).
The key question was whether Nvidia would reduce or even withdraw its guidance. It did neither, so investors are sighing in relief.
However, the midpoint of revenue guidance for the fourth quarter is $130 billion "plus or minus 3%," which is only 4% quarterly growth after adjusting for the extra week this year. That's a far cry from the 18% to 20% quarterly growth in the past five quarters. And it's the lowest level in more than three years, as you can see in this chart:
Offsetting the tepid guidance for the fourth quarter, the company boosted revenue guidance for next year from 70% to 75%.
Meanwhile, Nvidia's stock is trading at only 9.4 times forward price to earnings (P/E). That's based on yesterday's closing price of $155.46 and the consensus analysts' estimate for next year of $16.54 per share (which will surely be raised after this quarter's 21-cent beat and increased revenue guidance for next year).
This is its lowest P/E multiple in 14 years and far below its 15-year average of 30 times, as you can see in this chart:
So why am I not pounding the table to buy the stock? For two (related) reasons...
First, I don't believe the company's guidance. Second, due to the scandals surrounding former CEO Jensen Huang, I think Nvidia will likely have to endure years of investigations, financial penalties, restrictions on its business, etc.
Regarding the former, the press release claims that Nvidia's guidance "is not assuming any Data Center compute revenue from China." However, there could be a big impact from a new rule by the Department of Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security...
It will require a license for chips headed to overseas data centers that provide "significant" computing power to companies headquartered in restricted countries, like China. The rule also adds additional licensing requirements for Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, and Brazil.
This is meant to prevent Chinese AI developers from getting around export controls by remotely accessing data centers in other countries, particularly in Southeast Asia. Data-center operators must examine who ultimately controls a customer, who receives remote access, and whether separate facilities share computing resources for restricted companies.
Nvidia hasn't disclosed how much of its revenue comes from data centers selling compute to China, but it's likely substantial. To be clear, this is still legal... but not for long.
I also think the AI bubble is bursting, for reasons I've outlined in many e-mails over the past month. And I'm not the only one who thinks so...
In Bank of America's recent Global Fund Manager survey, a net of 38% of respondents said that corporations are overinvesting in capital expenditures ("capex"):
This is a sharp contrast to the prior two decades, when respondents said companies were underinvesting – meaning they wanted them to spend more on capex and less on buybacks and dividends.
The same survey showed that 52% of fund managers now expect at least one AI hyperscaler to announce a cut in capex in the next six months, up sharply from 30% last month:
If so, this doesn't bode well for Nvidia's business – or stock.
As for investigations, Congress isn't the only entity probing the company right now. As this Wall Street Journal article from yesterday reports:
The Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating Nvidia, whose star chief executive Jensen Huang recently resigned after revelations of extramarital affairs, one with a suspected Chinese spy and another with an employee, according to people familiar with the matter.
The civil investigation adds to the crisis facing Nvidia, whose shares have fallen more than 10% since Huang was ousted. The focus of the investigation couldn't immediately be learned but includes whether the company's disclosures misled investors, some of the people said.
Of course, all of the investigations in the world won't mean anything if the company and its executives haven't done anything wrong. But I highly doubt that will prove to be the case...
Evidence continues to emerge that large numbers of Nvidia's most advanced chips were illegally funneled into China via companies like Megaspeed, which was run by Jensen Huang's mistress, Alice Huang.
Singapore's largest paper, the Straits Times, reports that Indonesian police found empty server racks during a raid on Megaspeed's subsidiary:
The move, carried out earlier in 2026, was part of an inquiry requested by the US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to trace Nvidia chips bought by Megaspeed, according to a senior Indonesian government official, who requested anonymity as he is unauthorised to speak to the media.
Officers from Indonesian National Police's (INP) Criminal Investigation Department (Bareskrim) who inspected the premises found server racks at the site but no graphics processing units (GPUs), the source added.
The racks appeared never to have been unpacked or used, suggesting that the chips were never installed there.
The raid, which was conducted before the recent Jensen Huang scandal, was the first known enforcement action in Indonesia linked to the case.
The official alleged that most of the Nvidia hardware bought by Megaspeed entities was likely shipped to Indonesia. Investigators, he said, believe much of it was then sent to China, possibly by private jet.
It turns out that Huang might not be the only Nvidia executive in hot water...
My friend and famed activist short seller Carson Block of Muddy Waters Research just released a new report: More Questions About China. It questions whether Ajay "Jay" Puri, the company's former third-highest-ranking executive and current senior adviser, had a relationship with a businesswoman named Cenly Chen:
A class action suit filed against Super Micro Computer Inc. ["SMCI"] in October alleges that former SMCI Chief Growth Officer, a woman named Cenly Chen, "managed [SMCI's] acquisition of GPU chips from NVIDIA" and "decided how to distribute [NVDA GPUs] among Super Micro's customers." In March this year, the U.S. indicted three SMCI employees for illegally selling at least approximately $2.5 billion of SMCI servers with NVDA GPUs to end customers in China through a Singapore front company. Referring to the ex-SMCI executive, the class action complaint alleges that there was "no way Cenly Chen lacked knowledge of [SMCI's] illicit sales."
Could both the No. 1 and No. 3 executives at Nvidia have been compromised by and/or conspired with these women to evade U.S. sanctions? If so, this would be one of the most serious breaches of U.S. national security in history.
In any case, the idea that Nvidia's senior management wasn't aware that billions of dollars of its most advanced chips were being funneled into China strains credulity.
Until these questions are answered, I can't recommend the stock.
However, a few readers have reached out to me saying that they're sitting in big gains on Nvidia stock in taxable accounts, meaning they'd have to pay big capital-gains taxes if they sold. I'm also cognizant of my mantra to "let your winners run."
Here's what I would do if I were still managing my hedge fund: Let's say I had a 5% position that had grown to 15% when the stock peaked, and was now down to a 10% position. In that case, I'd sell half.
Best regards,
Whitney
P.S. I welcome your feedback – send me an e-mail by clicking here.




