The Most Dangerous Type of Stock in Today's Market

What would it take for a stock to fall 80%?

Not a bottom-of-the-barrel, junk stock... but one of the world's best brands?

This is no hypothetical scenario, by the way. And importantly, the culprit wasn't market turmoil. This stock plummeted during one of the most powerful bull markets in history.

So, if it wasn't the market, you'd probably assume it was a serious problem with the business... like a competitive threat or a major mistake from management.

You could dream up a dozen complicated reasons. But the explanation turns out to be fairly simple.

Today, I'll share it with you. And I'll share the simple lesson it teaches − one that could save your portfolio.

What Really Caused This 80% Crash

Finding a high-quality stock down 80% in today's market isn't impossible. Just take a look at sports-apparel giant Nike (NKE).

Nike is one of the most recognizable brands on the planet – so it's no wonder the stock has been an incredible winner for much of its history. But since their late-2021 peak, shares have collapsed around 80%... during a stellar bull market.

What could make such an established company crash that hard?

My friend Meb Faber tried to solve this mystery on an episode of his podcast, The Meb Faber Show. Specifically, he dug into how folks on social media platform X replied to the question, "What happened to Nike?"

Here's how he described their responses...

There's hundreds of comments. And the comments almost universally are like, "Oh, the product, the competitors or politics, [Colin] Kaepernick, macro," whatever it may be, all the things you would expect people to talk about.

In other words, folks brought up fundamental explanations. They assumed there was an underlying problem with the business. Some of them made good points.

But Meb had a different, much simpler explanation...

None of them mentioned the fact that the [price-to-earnings] ratio at the peak was like 70, and now it's 20.

How does a stock like Nike fall 80%? Easy... Expectations were sky-high.

All it had to do was go from outperforming expectations and being incredibly expensive... to underperforming expectations and watching its valuation collapse.

Paying a high price for a stock can sometimes work out – if it's a high-growth company. But often, a better approach, popularized by the "father of value investing," Benjamin Graham, is to figure out a business's long-term value – and buy it when it trades at a discount.

That discount is called your "margin of safety." It gives you wiggle room in case you made mistakes in your analysis... or the company hits headwinds... or the overall market enters a dry spell.

Folks who bought Nike at 70 times earnings gave themselves no margin of safety. They did the exact opposite... They practically doomed themselves from the start.

In simple terms, buying a stock for cheap means there are lots of ways things could go right. When expectations are low, it's easy to beat them – and make investors happy.

But a stock priced for perfection has no room for error. And there are lots of ways things can go wrong.

That's what happened for Nike. Its growth slowed, and competition increased. But the high price was the real killer – because at such a high valuation, the stock had nowhere to go but down.

Assuming a stable valuation, its overall decline would have been closer to 20%... far easier to stomach than an 80% collapse.

This kind of stock – one that carries a high valuation but has little or unreliable growth – is the most dangerous in today's market. Even minor business problems can cause that kind of stock to crash. In the case of Nike, the collapse meant investors lost 80% of their money.

Of course, you could easily avoid a loss like that by sticking with the trend. It's simple and profitable to only buy stocks that are going up. And it makes avoiding this kind of situation simple.

If you think any company is too high-quality to crash 80%, you're wrong. Nike proves it.

Good investing,

Brett Eversole


Editor's note: The market is approaching a major turning point that could determine the biggest winners – and losers – of 2027. That's why, today at 10 a.m. Eastern time, Brett is joining Joel Litman from our corporate affiliate Altimetry to share an urgent online briefing. They'll share the No. 1 move to make to stay ahead of what's coming... Save your free spot now.

Further Reading

Finding good growth investments can be challenging. But great investors know the secret: Capital allocation matters the most. And that means finding businesses that take advantage of the "flywheel effect."

As Brett often says, the trend is your friend. While tech stocks have seen some dips recently, their long-term trend remains firmly bullish. And some technical evidence suggests a bounce is on the way.

Back to Top